The Archive
Epstein Files

Jeffrey Epstein &

Michael Reiter

Former Palm Beach Police Chief

Key Facts

2001–2009

Tenure as Palm Beach Police Chief

Town of Palm Beach Municipal Records

Over 30 minor victims identified by PBPD under Reiter's supervision

Investigation Scope

DOJ OPR Report (2020)

October 20, 2005

Search Warrant Execution Date

Palm Beach Police Department Records

Joseph Recarey (PBPD)

Lead Detective Assigned

PBPD Incident Report (2005)

Editorial illustration of Michael Reiter

Michael Reiter · Former Palm Beach Police Chief

In March 2005, a distressed local woman walked into the Palm Beach Police Department to report that her fourteen-year-old stepdaughter was being sexually exploited by a wealthy financier living on El Brillo Way. The report landed on the desk of Chief of Police Michael Reiter, a veteran law enforcement executive who had led the department since 2001. Rather than treating the allegation as an isolated domestic matter, Reiter recognized the markers of systemic predatory behavior and authorized an extensive covert operation. Over the next three years, Reiter would find himself not merely investigating Jeffrey Epstein, but contending with an entrenched legal and political apparatus that repeatedly blunted local police efforts to bring the multimillionaire to trial.

Under Reiter's leadership, the Palm Beach Police Department launched an aggressive inquiry led by lead detective Joseph Recarey. Reiter shielded the investigative team from external pressures while directing officers to pursue every operational lead methodically. PBPD investigators conducted extensive surveillance outside Epstein's Palm Beach residence, analyzed phone logs, interviewed dozens of underage girls, and compiled evidence demonstrating an organized grooming network. By October 2005, Reiter's department had accumulated sufficient evidence to secure a search warrant for Epstein's estate. The subsequent raid yielded massage tables, cash, address books, and photographic evidence, providing physical corroboration for the victims' testimonies.

Public records and subsequent investigative reports document that Reiter expected the case to proceed swiftly to a multi-count felony indictment. By mid-2006, PBPD had prepared a comprehensive, probable-cause affidavit detailing offenses against multiple minors, arguing that Epstein was operating a criminal enterprise. However, Reiter encountered immediate resistance from Palm Beach County State Attorney Barry Krischer. Despite PBPD’s extensive evidentiary file, Krischer resisted filing primary felony charges, suggesting instead that the case be brought before a grand jury on a single count of soliciting prostitution. Reiter publicly and privately challenged this approach, viewing it as an unjustified downgrading of serial child abuse that ignored the depth of PBPD's findings.