The Archive
Epstein Files

Jeffrey Epstein &

Barry Krischer

Former Palm Beach County State Attorney

Key Facts

State Attorney for Florida's 15th Judicial Circuit (1993–2009)

Office Held

Multiple felony counts of unlawful sexual activity with a minor and sexual battery

Original Charges Sought

Palm Beach Police Department Probable Cause Affidavit (2006)

Single count of felony solicitation of prostitution

Grand Jury Indictment

Palm Beach County Grand Jury Indictment (June 2006)

Referred file directly to federal prosecutors after county office reduced scope

Police Action

DOJ Office of Professional Responsibility Report (2020)

Editorial illustration of Barry Krischer

Barry Krischer · Former Palm Beach County State Attorney

In the decades-long legal saga surrounding Jeffrey Epstein, few institutional figures have drawn as much initial scrutiny as Barry Krischer. As the State Attorney for Florida’s 15th Judicial Circuit, serving Palm Beach County from 1993 until his retirement in early 2009, Krischer was the chief local prosecutor tasked with evaluating the first extensive criminal probe into Epstein. That investigation, initiated by the Palm Beach Police Department in 2005, uncovered dozens of underage victims and established a blueprint of serial abuse. Yet, instead of resulting in heavy felony charges for sexual battery, the local prosecution culminated in a controversial grand jury indictment for misdemeanor solicitation, opening the door to federal intervention and ultimately the infamous 2008 non-prosecution agreement. The friction between local police investigators and Krischer’s office remains one of the foundational flashpoints in the public record of Epstein's legal maneuverings.

The inquiry into Epstein began in earnest in March 2005 when a concerned parent contacted the Palm Beach Police Department, alleging that a fourteen-year-old girl had been paid to undress and perform sexual acts at Epstein’s El Brillo Way mansion. Detective Joseph Recarey and Police Chief Michael Reiter spearheaded a methodical investigation that spanned over a year. The police gathered physical evidence, interviewed dozens of teenage girls who described an organized pyramid scheme of recruitment, and obtained a search warrant that was executed on Epstein’s residence in October 2005. By early 2006, the Palm Beach Police Department believed they had built an airtight case documenting multiple felony counts of unlawful sexual activity with minors and sexual battery. They formally referred the case to Krischer’s office with an expectation of direct filing of felony charges.

Rather than immediately filing direct felony charges—a standard prosecutorial tool routinely utilized in serious sexual assault cases in Florida—Krischer expressed profound skepticism regarding the credibility of the victims. According to internal memorandums, correspondence released under public records requests, and subsequent investigative journalism by the Miami Herald, Krischer’s prosecutors raised questions regarding whether the adolescent victims understood what they were participating in or were motivated by money. Internal documents revealed that local prosecutors debated whether the young women should be considered victims or accomplices in prostitution. This posture prompted intense private conflict between the Palm Beach Police Department and the State Attorney’s Office. Chief Reiter publicly and privately voiced frustration, asserting that the state was undermining an extraordinarily well-documented investigation into the exploitation of children.