The Archive
Epstein Files

Jeffrey Epstein &

Palm Beach Police Department

Municipal law enforcement agency, Florida

Key Facts

Joseph Recarey

Lead Detective

Palm Beach Police Department Records

Michael Reiter

Police Chief

Palm Beach Police Department Records

Over 30 victims and witnesses interviewed

Identified Minors (2005-2006)

PBPD Probable Cause Affidavit (2006)

358 El Brillo Way, Palm Beach, Florida

Search Location

PBPD Search Warrant (October 2005)

Editorial illustration of Palm Beach Police Department

Palm Beach Police Department · Municipal law enforcement agency, Florida

In March 2005, the Palm Beach Police Department initiated what would become the foundational criminal inquiry into Jeffrey Epstein. Operating within an affluent Florida barrier island known for strict privacy and high-profile residents, the municipal police agency was suddenly tasked with examining allegations against one of its wealthiest homeowners. A local parent arrived at police headquarters to report that a 14-year-old girl had been brought to Epstein’s waterfront estate at 358 El Brillo Way and paid hundreds of dollars to undress and provide massages. The complaint landed on the desk of Detective Joseph Recarey, setting off an intensive, multi-month local investigation that ultimately exposed a vast trafficking operation operating in plain sight.

Under the direction of Police Chief Michael Reiter, the department pursued the complaint not as an isolated incident, but as a potential pattern of predatory conduct. Detective Recarey systematically interviewed local teenagers across Palm Beach County, identifying dozens of girls who described a recruitment pyramid scheme orchestrated by Epstein and his associates. The teenagers recounted being paid several hundred dollars per session to perform sexual acts, with additional financial bounties offered if they recruited their high school classmates. Police records released through subsequent public records disclosures reveal that within months, investigators had accumulated statements from more than thirty young women and minors detailing encounters inside the El Brillo Way residence.

In October 2005, the Palm Beach Police Department obtained and executed a criminal search warrant on Epstein’s property. Inside the sprawling mansion, officers seized computer hard drives, telephone logs, surveillance footage, and handwritten scheduling books. Investigative summaries indicate that detectives discovered numerous framed photographs of underage girls, massage tables surrounded by toiletries and sex toys, and evidence suggesting extensive surveillance equipment inside private suites. The physical evidence corroborated the accounts gathered during victim interviews, establishing that minors were routinely transported to the property during Epstein’s visits to Palm Beach.