The Archive
Epstein Files

Jeffrey Epstein &

Michael F. Reiter

Former Palm Beach Police Chief

Key Facts

Chief of Police, Town of Palm Beach Police Department (2001–2009)

Official Role

Town of Palm Beach Municipal Records

Directed the initial 2005–2006 criminal probe that identified dozens of underage victims

Primary Investigative Action

Palm Beach Police Department Incident Report (2005)

Publicly clashed with State Attorney Barry Krischer over grand jury leniency

Key Institutional Conflict

Department of Justice OPR Report (2020)

Delivered state investigative files directly to the FBI after local prosecutors balked

Federal Escalation

Miami Herald (2018)

Editorial illustration of Michael F. Reiter

Michael F. Reiter · Former Palm Beach Police Chief

In the spring of 2005, when an allegation of child sexual abuse involving a high-profile Palm Beach resident reached local law enforcement, the jurisdictional responsibility landed squarely on Michael F. Reiter, then the Chief of Police for the Town of Palm Beach. Over the course of the following three years, Reiter and his investigative team spearheaded what remains the most foundational, ground-level criminal investigation into Jeffrey Epstein. Rather than bending to the immense political and financial influence of the financier, Reiter oversaw a rigorous, evidence-driven inquiry that uncovered an extensive network of underage exploitation, bringing his department into direct, protracted conflict with both county prosecutors and federal officials.

Reiter had taken command of the Palm Beach Police Department in 2001, heading an agency accustomed to handling high-net-worth residents and discrete security concerns rather than complex predatory networks. That dynamic shifted permanently in March 2005, when a local parent brought a fourteen-year-old girl to the police station. The teenager recounted being paid to provide sexual massages to Epstein at his waterfront mansion on El Brillo Way. Recognizing the severity of the allegations, Reiter tasked veteran detective Joseph Recarey with leading the day-to-day legwork while ensuring the department insulated the detectives from outside interference. Under Reiter’s leadership, the department chose not to treat the case as an isolated local dispute, but as an active, organized ring operating within their municipality.

By October 2005, the Palm Beach Police Department had accumulated enough probable cause to secure a search warrant for Epstein’s residence. The raid yielded crucial evidence, including computer hard drives, massage appointment logs, hidden camera apparatus, and contact books containing the names and numbers of dozens of adolescent girls. Reiter supported his detectives as they conducted painstaking field interviews, eventually identifying dozens of potential victims and secondary recruiters who had been brought into Epstein’s orbit. The resulting investigative file, spanning hundreds of pages, outlined systematic statutory rape, procurement of minors for prostitution, and unlawful sexual activity with children, establishing a detailed evidentiary blueprint that would define the Epstein scandal for the next two decades.