The Archive
Epstein Files

Jeffrey Epstein &

Jeffrey Pagliuca

Criminal Defense Attorney

Key Facts

Lead trial counsel for Ghislaine Maxwell at law firm Haddon, Morgan and Foreman P.C.

Role

SDNY Court Dockets

U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York and U.S. Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit

Primary Venues

Federal Court Records

Argued Maxwell was a scapegoat for Jeffrey Epstein and invoked Epstein's 2008 Non-Prosecution Agreement

Primary Defense Strategy

United States v. Maxwell Pretrial Filings (2020-2021)

Ghislaine Maxwell convicted on five felony counts and sentenced to 20 years imprisonment

Trial Outcome

SDNY Sentencing Judgment (June 2022)

Editorial illustration of Jeffrey Pagliuca

Jeffrey Pagliuca · Criminal Defense Attorney

In the sprawling legal and financial wreckage left in the wake of Jeffrey Epstein, few defense attorneys have occupied as pivotal an operational role as Jeffrey S. Pagliuca. A veteran criminal trial lawyer based in Denver, Colorado, and a named partner at the litigation boutique Haddon, Morgan and Foreman P.C., Pagliuca entered the Epstein ecosystem not as an associate or financier, but as the principal legal shield for Epstein’s longtime confidante and convicted co-conspirator, Ghislaine Maxwell. Spanning nearly a decade of high-stakes civil and criminal proceedings in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York, Pagliuca’s advocacy sat directly at the intersection of civil discovery battles, secret settlement agreements, and the eventual criminal prosecution that exposed the inner workings of Epstein’s sex-trafficking enterprise.

Pagliuca first engaged with the Epstein orbit in September 2015, following the filing of a landmark civil defamation lawsuit by Virginia Roberts Giuffre against Maxwell. Giuffre alleged that Maxwell had publicly branded her a liar after she came forward with claims of being sexually abused by Epstein and trafficked to prominent global figures. Maxwell retained Haddon, Morgan and Foreman, thrusting Pagliuca and his law partner, Laura Menninger, to the center of the controversy. From the outset, Pagliuca’s strategy was aggressively combative. Court dockets indicate that his team sought to restrict Giuffre's discovery demands, aggressively seeking to prevent the public disclosure of flight logs, address books, and Maxwell’s sworn depositions. Pagliuca argued that the civil litigation was an improper vehicle designed to harass Maxwell and expose private records that had no bearing on Giuffre’s specific defamation claims.

During the contentious 2016 depositions in the Giuffre litigation, Pagliuca sat beside Maxwell over multiple days as she answered—and frequently declined to answer—intense questioning regarding Epstein’s residences, private aircraft, and the presence of minor girls in Palm Beach, New York, and the U.S. Virgin Islands. Pagliuca repeatedly objected on the record, invoking personal privacy concerns and claiming questions exceeded the allowable scope. While the civil lawsuit was ultimately settled under confidential terms in May 2017, Pagliuca’s legal maneuvers inadvertently created the very documentation that would later dismantle Maxwell's defense. A subsequent legal fight spearheaded by news organizations and Giuffre's counsel led federal judges Loretta Preska and later the Second Circuit Court of Appeals to unseal hundreds of pages of these transcripts, which federal prosecutors thoroughly parsed in their criminal investigation.